Meeting Minutes: 2025/03/11 OpenSCENARIO DSL CCB
| Location | MS Teams |
| Date | 11/03/2025 |
| Time | 14:00 to 15:00 (CET) |
| Note taker | CoPilot |
Antitrust reminder
Every participant acknowledges that they know the content of the antitrust reminder: ASAM Antitrust Reminder
Participants
| Participant | Company | Presence |
|---|---|---|
| @anandraj.desai.vayavyalabs | Vayavya Labs | N |
| @dCarruth | Mississippi State University | N |
| @fbock | CARIAD SE | N |
| @gil.amid , @robert.scholz, @rhadar | Foretellix | Y |
| @Kathy.Zhao | Bosch | N |
| @kyucheol.choi | AVL | N |
| @n.ochoa | DENSO Automotive | Y |
| @pmai | PMSF IT | N |
| @Rolf.Magnus2 | Akkodis | Y |
| @Wenyuan.Wei | CATARC | N |
| @AhmedSadek @yash.shah @dsanchez | ASAM Office | Y |
Agenda/Goals
| TOP | Topic | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Meeting minutes handling / storage | |
| 2 | Discussion on #804 | Open |
| 3 | Discussion on P_2025_02-006: Additional Language Constructs in OpenSCENARIO DSL simulation/openx#10 | Open |
| 4 | DSL Maintenance: simulation/openx#30 | |
Minutes
Generated by AI. Be sure to check for accuracy.
Meeting notes:
-
Meeting Minutes Handling: Diego mentioned the storing of meeting minutes as issues tagged with "CCB meeting minutes" and closing previous ones to avoid a long list. The team agreed to this approach. Diego also discussed the challenge of storing meeting minutes for projects affecting multiple standards. He mentioned that the ASAM Office is evaluating options like using a global repository, SharePoint, or wiki for better accessibility and storage capacity.
-
Incorrect Composition Explanation: Rolf and Ronen discussed the semantics of speed ranges in the standard, highlighting a potential contradiction in the definition of speed ranges. They agreed to further investigate and propose a solution.
Rolf believes that a single speed value should be selected and kept throughout the entire phase, while Ronen argues that the speed can vary within the defined range during the phase.
- Further Investigation: It was agreed to further investigate the issue and propose a solution to address the contradiction in the standard.
-
Phase Transition Semantics: Gil pointed out the need to define the handling of phase transitions in the standard to ensure continuity. Rolf agreed to research and propose a definition.
-
Additional Language Constructs: Gil proposed developing detailed definitions for additional language constructs as part of the maintenance project.
-
Maintenance Project Kickoff: Diego and Ahmed confirmed the participants for the DSL maintenance project, including Ronen, Rolf, Robert, Pierre, and Gil. They agreed to start the project and allocate time for discussions in the CCB meetings.
- Domain Model Changes: Max volunteered check the missing "change_orientation" issue and to provide definitions for domain model changes related to position 2D and geodetic position 3D. He will align also with Nicolas .
Follow-up tasks:
- Meeting Minutes Handling: Evaluate and present options for storing and handling meeting minutes (ASAM)
- Speed Modifier Semantics: Research and summarize the current rules and contradictions regarding the speed modifier semantics and phase transitions, and propose a solution. (Rolf)
- Additional Language Constructs: Develop a detailed definition for the proposed additional language constructs and present it to the CCB for approval. (Gil, Ronan, Robert)
- CCB Enrollment: Send an email to Max with details about CCB membership and meeting schedules. (ASAM)
- Domain Model Changes: Prepare a definition for the domain model changes related to position 2D and 3D and discuss it with Nicolas before presenting to the CCB. (Max)